Chamber of Justice - Multiple Verdicts

   6

Chamber of Justice - Multiple Verdicts

Members of the Dark Jedi Brotherhood -

The Chamber of Justice has convened in seven matters, having brought charges against members and completed the process of adjudication for each case. The Chamber has issued detailed verdicts and Justicar Opinions for each case which can be found in the PDF files linked below. The primary opinion, which was incorporated by reference into other opinions due to overlapping issues, is the DB v. Delak Krennel opinion. I direct you attention to that opinion first. Please note that the written opinion is generally found on the second page of the following documents, after announcement of the verdict.

The cases and verdicts are summarized as follows:

Case # 42 - DB v. Delak Krennel - Opinion PDF

  • Count 1 - Cheating - GUILTY by plea
  • Count 2 - Falsifying Matches - GUILTY by plea
  • Punishment - Two-grade Demotion, LoR, Strict Probation w/Gaming Ban

Case # 43 - DB v. Rayna Krennel - Opinion PDF

  • Count 1 - Cheating - GUILTY by plea
  • Punishment - Two-grade Demotion, LoR, Strict Probation

Case # 44 - DB v. Darkblade - Opinion PDF

  • Count 1 - Cheating - GUILTY by plea
  • Punishment - Two-grade Demotion, LoR, Strict Probation

Case # 45 - DB v. Chizz - Opinion PDF

  • Count 1 - Cheating - GUILTY through Trial by Justicar. No plea entered.
  • Punishment - Two-grade Demotion, LoR, Strict Probation

Case # 46 - DB v. Shorurra - Opinion PDF

  • Count 1 - Falsifying Matches - GUILTY through Trial by Justicar. No plea entered.
  • Punishment - LoR, Strict Probation w/Gaming Ban

Case # 47 - DB v. Turel Sorenn - Opinion PDF

  • Count 1 - Falsifying Matches - GUILTY by plea
  • Punishment - LoR, General Probation

Case # 48 - DB v. Nicolai "Rod" Rodell - Opinion PDF

  • Count 1 - Falsifying Matches - GUILTY by plea
  • Punishment - LoR, Strict Probation w/Gaming Ban

It brings me no joy to issue these opinions, but it is necessary. These members have each made mistakes, and have now paid for their mistakes. Let us now forgive and move on.

Signed and sealed in Justice,

Jac Ae-Sequiera Cotelin

Justicar and High Protector of the Dark Jedi Brotherhood

One additional comment: I do not consider it to be falsification of matches for someone to take a bio break in the middle of a D3 or TOR or whatever gaming session. It is the sustained absences, often intentional, that made these Falsification claims stick. If you are breaking for 10 minutes or longer (or having frequent breaks), while everyone else is still playing and earning you CFs, you may be getting to the breaking point of reasonableness.

Use your best judgment. If you need to step away, then perhaps you need to drop game and come back later.

Jac

Thank you, Jac (Monty and Halc) for the clear and concise verdicts and the speedy resolution to the issue. I really like the opinions as it gives us not-involved in the "legal" process a way to see your individual thought process on the proceedings.

Here's to forgiving, moving on, and learning from our past experiences.

As Wally said, thank you for the quick and speedy resolution. I know that those charged no doubt appreciation the curtailment of what was once unending suspense. And thank you for the Opinions. They do much to clarify the rationale behind the rulings.

About time :D thanks for the judgement and let's roll on ^^

Thank you to Jac, Monty, Halc, and all else involved in the Chamber proceedings for the timely and transparent verdicts. These cases could have been the source of much stress but were handled quickly, sensibly, and amicably. We all greatly appreciate it.

As you have said, we move forward and forgive. Let this all be behind us as we do better in the future.

Sorry to see so many journeymen in trouble for something like this. Shows to me that proper training wasn't instilled correctly.

Hope they all learned a valuable lesson and be happy to see them reclaim their previous ranks through honest work.

Thanks jac for speeding their resolutions.

You need to be logged in to post comments