Privateer Jon Silvon vs. General Zentru'la

Privateer Jon Silvon

Equite 1, Equite tier, Clan Scholae Palatinae
Male Human, Mercenary, Scoundrel
vs.

General Zentru'la

Elder 1, Elder tier, Unaffiliated
Male Twi'lek, Loyalist, Weapons Specialist
Comment

It's always a nice change of pace to see a match on the funderdome. Time to take a break from high-paced competitive action and focus in on a friendly dance competition between two friends. Thank you both for this story, I found it a joy to read.

Mechanically you both had few issues, though Jon's posts in general had more frequent spelling and grammatical errors. Very well done on both sides

A single realism error was noted in Jon's post, costing a crucial point, but the sentiment behind the error should be noted by both participants. Leaning on the fourth wall is acceptable to a degree in the ACC, and sly comedic references to the real world can add a lot to the story. However, anything that brings the reader explicitly out of the setting should be avoided carefully.

In terms of story I loved both sets of posts for different reasons. Jon's posts presented a fast paced comedy with brilliant dialogue and some funny gags. Meanwhile Zentru'la slowed down to take a look at inner monologue, and even took a sudden dive towards drama in his ending. While I preferred Zentru'La's ending, I felt that Jon's posts were overall more fun and engaging enough to earn him advantage.

When all this is taken into account realism appears to be the crucial measure of the match here. Though Jon's advantage on story ensured the margin was narrow, Zentru'la is the winner of this match. Well done to both of you.

Hall Unconventional Hall - Ranked
Messages 4 out of 4
Time Limit 7 Days
Battle Style Singular Ending
Battle Status Judged
Combatants Privateer Jon Silvon, General Zentru'la
Winner General Zentru'la
Force Setting Standard
Weapon Setting Standard
Privateer Jon Silvon's Character Snapshot Snapshot
General Zentru'la's Character Snapshot Snapshot
Venue Coruscant: Club Kasakar
Last Post 31 August, 2019 1:36 PM UTC
Assigned Judge Grot
Syntax - 15%
General Zentru'la Major Jon Silvon
Score: 4 (Advantage) Score: 4
Rationale: A few minor grammatical errors. Rationale: Minor spelling mistakes and grammatical errors.
Story - 40%
General Zentru'la Major Jon Silvon
Score: 4 Score: 4 (Advantage)
Rationale: Extremely well written and engaging. The ending in particular with its sudden turn towards drama had me hooked. A look at the characters inner monologues was sorely needed in this match. in general, however, I felt it lacked some energy and the pacing began to drag. Rationale: The story was funny, raucous, and engaging. Most especially the interaction and dialogue between the two characters was enough to win more over here. They play off eachother so perfectly.
Realism - 25%
General Zentru'la Major Jon Silvon
Score: 5 Score: 4
Rationale: No errors. Rationale: A single error was noted.
Continuity - 20%
General Zentru'la Major Jon Silvon
Score: 5 Score: 5
Rationale: No errors. Rationale: No errors.
General Zentru'la's Score: 4.52 Major Jon Silvon's Score: 4.4
Posts

Coruscant Club Kasakar

Anakin once visited Coruscant’s underbelly, as an escort for Supreme Chancellor Palpatine’s secret visit. Festering within the 2685th level of Coruscant, it is a feeding ground to the best and worst criminals—bureaucrats among them. Slaves and contraband are bought and sold on the hour, while others gamble with their lives or ill-gotten gains on the roll of a chance cube.

Others are content to seek entertainment, watching holographic projections of exotic dancers in various states of undress—the likes of which will no doubt be traded as slaves in exchange for credits or other services. Games of chance are often obscured under the sheer volume of patrons gathered around the game tables. Smaller round tables serve for social or business gatherings, with more discreet booths tucked into alcoves along the walls.

Having undergone unfinished renovations at some point, the ceiling has been raised to resemble that of a warehouse. Smoke gathers among the durasteel supports, making a buffer for the intense red and violet beams lighting the cesspit below. Zeltron perfumes are among the most common smells in the establishment, while the rolling of dice cubes make for the most recognizable sound above the music. Fights don’t often break out, and violence is often dissuaded at the sight of armoured bouncers several heads taller than most humanoids

“Ah, C’m ooon, Gen’ral!” Jon slurred, swinging one arm over Zentru'la’s broad shoulders. “Your not even tryin’ to have a good time here!”

Zentru'la grimaced at the touch, but the pirate/spy either failed to notice, or deliberately ignored his displeasure; with Silvon, you really never could tell, or at least Zentru'la hadn’t learned to.

“This,” Zentru'la growled, gesturing to the room full of blinking lights, pounding music, and drunken patrons irritably, “Is not my idea of ‘fun’, Captain.”

“But, come oooooon,” Jon said, patting the general’s chest. “The Empress, long may she, uhm, raid!” Jon shouted, giving a sloppy attempt at a salute. “She, she explicitly ordered me to see to it that you relax tonight! Your daughter cares about you a lot, you know? She has such a big heart…”

What my daughter has, Zentru'la thought to himself as he eyed his “companion” with distaste, is a sadistic sense of humor.

After a while longer of enduring Jon’s drunken company, the good general was finally pulled out of his brooding when Jon grabbed him by the arm and started pulling him to the stage at the center of the bar.

“Jon, what is the meaning of-” Zentru'la froze upon seeing the words holographically projected over the head of the stage.

“DANCE-OFF COMPETITION, ALL COMERS WELCOME!”

By the time the general had snapped out his initial shock, he realized Jon had already paid the attendant and registered the two of them.

“...No.” Zentru'la said simply before turning to walk away.

“Yes!” Jon laughed, grabbing Zentru'la’s arm. Before Zentru'la had the oppurtunity to crush his fragile windpipe, the music started.

Grot, 12 September, 2019 12:53 AM UTC

Positive Takeaways

I really enjoy the comedy in this match. Jon and Zentru'la are set up as a classic stooge and straight-man, with Jon's drunken revelry playing perfectly off of Zentru'la's annoyed stoicism. This sort of thing is what the funderdome was made for.

Aside from the comedy, just the dialogue between the two characters felt very natural and extremely pleasant to read. There's clearly a skilled understanding of both characters on display. It should be noted as well that accents or in this case… slurred speech are often hard to pull off in dialogue, Jon managed it expertly.

Can be Improved

Some minor punctuation and spelling mistakes were noted.

The setting felt a little left by the wayside compared to the interaction between the two characters. You're both clearly at a bar, but if it weren't for the setting details I'd have no idea what sort of bar, how big the bar is, what planet you guys were on, etc. Some more love and attention could have been paid to setting the scene and drawing the audience into it.

Zentru’la aggressively snatched his colossal arm away from the clutches of Jon’s much weaker hand. He had heard stories of Captain Silvon from those under his command, the quirky human, with his eccentric behaviour and carefree approach towards life, had been called many adjectives ranging from fool to lunatic. The General finally understood why.

“I said no, Silvon,” he growled to Jon. Zentru’la had absolutely no interest in this dance-off competition or the establishment. He had wasted enough time in his life already, now he was 62 and had things he needed to achieve before he became too old, this was a waste of time he couldn’t afford to waste… and their argument had begun to draw unwanted attention. Had Silvon not been useful to the Empire, he’d have slammed him into the floor by now.

Zentru’la’s eyes, constantly scanning for threats, caught the sight of the bouncers taking a close look at the two. It didn’t help that a clearing had formed around them, club patrons spreading from the growing tension between the exuberant human and the giant armoured twi’lek mountain.

Jon, however, was neither taking the General’s ‘no’ for an answer or relenting with the unwanted physical contact, responding to Zentru’la retracting his arm by grabbing him by the opposite shoulder. Zentru’la’s reactions kicked in, and his arm moved across to push Silvon’s away. Silvon made to grab on the other side, and again a powerful twi’lek arm brushed his attempt to the side. “Now you’re getting into it!” Silvon laughed, making more grabs at the General as he became progressively irritated. “Make those shapes!” He made to grab both of Zentru’la’s shoulders. “Give me a Y!” He baited Zentru’la’s guard central and downwards. “M!”

Grot, 12 September, 2019 12:53 AM UTC

Positive Takeaways

The dance-fighting is inspired, like something out of a cheesy kung-fu movie and I love it. You easily take the premise your opponent set up and run with it, making something very entertaining.

You're style of writing is much less focused on dialogue compared to the first, and it's nice to get a look at Zentru'la's inner monologue and thoughts. It's a change of pace, and definitely not unwelcome. There is always more to the character than what one verbalizes, and this is used to great effect to get a deeper feel for the character and what is running through his head.

Can be Improved

A few spelling mistakes and run-on sentences.

The writing can get repetitive and uninteresting in places. Most egregiously was the following passage where it felt like you repeated yourself thrice,

He had wasted enough time in his life already, now he was 62 and had things he needed to achieve before he became too old, this was a waste of time he couldn’t afford to waste

Jon carried on like that for several more minutes. Each time the esteemed general attempted either to leave or to strike at his “dance partner”, the fool captain would find a way to turn it around into some other kind of dance move instead.

And, to Zentru'la’s chagrin, the crowd was loving it.

“C!” Jon cheered, twisting Zentru'la’s attempted chokehold into a (very) rough “C” shape.

I am going to kill this man, Zentru'la thought to himself. Slowly, and painfully.

“See General?” Jon said cheerily, as he ducked under one of the general’s swings, grabbing his arm in the process, before hoisting it into the air. “We’re winning!”

“Silvon, I don’t care what my daughter says, if you don’t release me this instant, I will kick your-”

“A!” Jon (and the rest of the now applauding crowd) shouted, positioning himself and the general in such a way that, indeed, it did look like the two of them formed and a large, if wildly lopsided, “A”.

With a lightsaber, Zentru'la snarled inwardly. Right through his-

“YYYYY-M-C-A!” Jon sang along with the audience. “It’s fun to stay at the-”

“TIME!” a droid’s voice boomed from the speakers above them, as the music and lights cut out. “ALL CONTESTANTS, PLEASE VACATE THE STAGE! FINAL JUDGING WILL BE ANNOUNCED SHORTLY!”

Zentru'la seized the opportunity and stalked off the stage, dragging Jon by his collar. Once the pair reached their original table, he practically through Jon into his seat.

“I certainly hope you had your fun,” Zentru'la growled. “Because we’re leaving, and once we reach Imperial space I’m going to-”

“You don’t even wanna stick around to see if we one?” Jon asked innocently, already reaching for another glass that had been left on the table.

“Silvon!” Zentru'la shouted. “Enough! Your little joke is over!”

“Almost.” Jon replied.

“ANNOUNCING THE WINNER’S OF TONIGHTS ALL-AROUND-THE-GALAXY-DANCE-COMPETEITION!” the same mechanical voice from before called. “BY UNANIMOUS, AND OVERWHELMING DECISION: JON THE BOMB, AND GENNY-ZENNY!” The patron instantly erupted in applause and cheering that made the room shake, and Zentru'la’s head pound. Or maybe that was the rage.

“Now the joke is over!” Jon chuckled, and the look in his eye was just a little too… clear for Zentru'la to truly to believe he was really as drunk as he acted.

Yeah, definitely the rage.

Grot, 12 September, 2019 12:56 AM UTC

Positive Takeaways

This had me genuinely laughing, which in such a comedic match, is a really good sign. The interaction between the two characters was so natural and engaging, it simply took me away with the flow of the story. Plus, it's not everyday you get to see two characters doing the YMCA dance while fighting on a dance floor.

Can be Improved

Again, a small number of spelling and grammar mistakes were noted.

A realism warning has to go out for Jon singing the lyrics to YMCA. I'm all fine with some fourth-wall leaning with the dancing, butnthe lyrics felt a step too far. While the funderdome has a naturally looser and more open-ended premise than the dueling hall, it still takes place in the contemporary Star Wars universe. As much as we all want it, there's no evidence supporting the existence of the Village People in Star Wars.

Zentru’la wished he could pick Silvon up and slam his face onto the club floor. But through the rage he was a consummate professional and this wasn’t the time or the place to be making a scene. Besides, as eccentric and crazy as Silvon was, he was a talented individual and useful to Scholae Palatinae. Instead, he just grabbed him firmly by the collar. “We’re leaving. Now.”

Jon tried to pull away from the General’s grip, but he was too strong. “Come on Genny Zenny! The people want more!”

“Now.” Zentru’la repeated firmly, tightening his grip and dragging the Privateer across the club like a bouncer escorting an unruly drunkard. “You’ve had your fun, it’s time to go.” He wasn’t taking no for an answer this time, and pulled Jon out of the club through the crowd of people, ignoring their protests and calls for more of Jon the Bomb and Genny-Zenny, not stopping until they were outside in the cold, fresh air.

Outside, and away from the commotion of the nightclub revellers, Zentru’la lifted Jon by the throat, slamming him against the wall back-first and holding him there. “War is coming!” the General shouted in his face.

“Relax Zenny! Everything will be fine, lets have more drinks,” Jon tried to squirm out of his grip.

“This isn’t a joke Silvon!” Zentru’la readjusted, holding him still with raw power. “Our enemies are gathering strength! Meraxis destroyed both our star destroyers! The Collective are up to something!” He let Silvon to the floor. “You’re a good fighter and a good pilot. The Empress needs her best men to be at the top of their game in the war to come.

Zentru’la turned and walked away. He had said everything he needed to say. This excursion had been a total waste of time for him, and now it was time to get back to training to prepare for the war.

Grot, 12 September, 2019 12:56 AM UTC

Positive Takeaways

The sudden switch to a dramatic and forceful tone here in the ending was very well done. It brings the audience out of the slice of life comedy and reminds them of the serious consequences and implications of the Star Wars setting. It's a dangerous universe, and while going out partying with aliens might be fun, it feels right to be reminded of the danger and drama of the setting.

Can be Improved

A few minor punctuation mistakes were noted.

The ending is short and sudden, and I would have liked to see a lot more expansion on the drama here. This really was the time to delve deep and bring forward the emotions of not just Zentru'la, but Jon as well. This is a great beginning for an ending, but I feel it could have been expanded into something more.